Nyleen Marshall was a vibrant, spirited four-year-old who resided in Clancy, Montana. Her parents, Bill and Nancy Briscoe, separated soon after her birth. Nancy remarried a man named Kim Marshall, who adopted Nyleen along with her elder brother, Nathan. When Nyleen was three, Nancy welcomed another daughter, Noreen. Delighted with her new role as an older sister, Nyleen embraced the joy of sibling companionship, and the trio relished an idyllic childhood amidst Montana’s scenic beauty, spending countless hours in the great outdoors.
Kim, an active member of the Capital City Amateur Radio Club, brought his family to a club-sponsored field day in the secluded Elkhorn Mountains on Saturday, June 25, 1983. The event took place within Helena National Forest, a remote area where only the club members were present that day. They enjoyed a leisurely picnic, after which the children played by wading in Maupin Creek and pursuing frogs.
Around 4:00 p.m., Nyleen grew weary of chasing frogs and decided to rest. She seated herself near some beaver dams along the creek, possibly hoping that a still presence might attract the elusive beavers. Some other children noticed her sitting alone, yet a moment later, she vanished from sight. Alarmed, they alerted the adults, and a search quickly commenced.
Realizing Nyleen was nowhere in the immediate vicinity, a call was made to the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office, which promptly involved the experienced Lewis and Clark County Search and Rescue team. With expertise in navigating the rugged Elkhorn terrain, the team initiated a systematic grid search, covering the area where Nyleen was last seen and extending along all accessible trails. A tracking dog briefly picked up her scent before it faded away.
Barefoot and dressed in just a t-shirt and shorts, Nyleen would have struggled to travel far over the rough terrain. As night descended, Kim and Nancy’s anxiety intensified, and Nancy remarked on how her daughter had been taught essential outdoor safety, knowing well to stay close to the group. The situation seemed unfathomable.
Despite the darkness, some search team members persisted, certain that Nyleen must be close. Statistics indicated most missing children were found within a mile and a half of their last location. However, searchers worried that, fearing trouble, Nyleen might have hidden from them. They knew that if she’d huddled somewhere within dense undergrowth, they could unknowingly pass by without spotting her.
At dawn on Sunday, the search resumed with renewed vigor. Hundreds of volunteers joined the effort, and search dogs were brought in from across the state. Moving in a meticulous formation, they scoured every conceivable hiding place, even examining all local mine shafts, but found no trace of the little girl.
Divers explored Maupin Creek and the surrounding ponds, eventually draining the area near the beaver dams and searching thoroughly. But the search yielded no clues—no clothing, no footprints, not even a strand of hair.
By Sunday afternoon, rain began to pour, and concerns for Nyleen’s well-being grew. While daytime temperatures had been mild, night temperatures had dipped into the 40s, threatening her survival without shelter. On Monday, thick fog rolled in, and heavy thunderstorms forced the search to pause. For safety, untrained volunteers were asked to refrain from entering the perilous mountain terrain, while others handed out flyers and raised funds to support the search effort. Kim and Nancy were deeply moved by the community’s response and expressed heartfelt gratitude to all involved.
Before dawn on Tuesday, a National Guard helicopter equipped with heat-sensing radar swept the area multiple times but failed to detect any sign of Nyleen. Kim and Nancy, visibly distraught, began to fear their daughter had been abducted and was no longer in the mountains, though police disagreed, believing the remoteness of the area made abduction unlikely.
In questioning attendees of the radio club event, investigators ruled out the involvement of club members. However, children’s accounts suggested the possible presence of an unknown man near the creek around the time Nyleen went missing. One child reported seeing a man in a purple jogging suit who attempted to speak with her, though she ignored him. Another child recounted a similar encounter, saying the man emerged from the woods and spoke to her before she fled. She suspected that Nyleen might have responded to the man. A third child corroborated these accounts, recalling that Nyleen mentioned “following the shadow” before she disappeared.
The children’s independent testimonies lent credibility to the possibility of a stranger’s presence. Police broadened their focus, exploring other scenarios even as they maintained their physical search in the mountains.
Over the following days, the search area expanded significantly, stretching more than eight miles in every direction. Due to the dense underbrush and steep slopes, all efforts had to be conducted on foot, making it one of the most exhaustive searches in Montana’s history. Yet despite the extensive efforts, no evidence of Nyleen’s whereabouts surfaced. After ten days, the official search concluded, with medical professionals acknowledging the slim chances of her survival in the wilderness. Some volunteers, however, continued searching for any remains.
Kim and Nancy held steadfast to the belief that Nyleen had been abducted. They worked tirelessly to keep her story alive, distributing flyers nationwide and placing her missing person poster on milk cartons. This outreach led to several leads, but each one proved fruitless.
Two years after her disappearance, an anonymous caller contacted the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, claiming to have taken Nyleen. He offered no further details before hanging up. In January 1986, another anonymous letter arrived, this time from a man claiming he had abducted a girl named “Kay” and was raising her as his own. He included specific details known only to those involved in Nyleen’s case, leading investigators to believe he might indeed be her abductor. The man claimed he loved the child and had no intention of returning her, stating he had traveled with her across various locations within and outside the U.S. Over the following months, he sent additional letters and made calls from payphones in Wisconsin. Despite FBI surveillance, the communications ceased, leaving investigators at a dead end.
In 1991, a man named Richard James Wilson, who had a history of mental illness, confessed to killing Nyleen and leaving her body in an Elkhorn Mountains mine shaft. However, inconsistencies in his account cast doubt on his story. A subsequent search found no evidence to substantiate his claims, and he later admitted his confession was false.
Nyleen’s case continues to draw attention, with numerous discussions online, yet no new leads have emerged in years. Some believe Nyleen may have been abducted and is possibly still alive, perhaps unaware of her true identity. Others think she may have succumbed to the elements within Helena National Forest, hidden in an unreachable crevice. While her case has gone cold for decades, investigators remain hopeful that one day the truth will come to light.
Nyleen Kaye Marshall was four years old when she vanished in 1983. She has brown hair, blue eyes, dimples when she smiles, and a small mole above her left eyebrow. At the time, she stood 3 feet 3 inches tall and weighed 29 pounds. She was last seen in shorts and a yellow shirt. If you have any information about Nyleen, please contact the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office at 406–225–4075.
0 Comments